Digital Slide Evaluation Rules

DIGITAL CRITIQUE RULES – (Projected Images)

January 2010

CATEGORIES:

PICTORIAL: If an image has been digitally modified and the result is an image that could have existed realistically, it will be considered Color Pictorial. 

Division I:  This division will consist of those who have scored in the top half of the entrants in the previous year.

Division II:  This division will consist of those who have scored in the lower half of the entrants in the previous year.  Any members entering images for the first time will be assigned to Division II.

Three digital images may be entered in each critique.  There will be five critiques per year.

MONOCHROME:  Image may be black and white or toned.  Toning must be a single tone over the entire print.  Images with color in a single spot or in separate areas do not qualify as Monochromatic.  One (1) image may be entered in each critique. There will be five critiques per year.

ALTERED REALITY:  If any image has been digitally modified and results in an image that could not possibly have existed in reality but with a base photograph(s) evident, it will be considered as Altered Reality.  One (1) image may be entered.  There will be three altered reality critiques per year.

SELECTED SUBJECT:  The image must contain the selected subject as its main element. One image may be entered. There will be two special subject critiques per year.

IMAGE CONTENT:

Images must be the product of a photographic process produced by the entrant.  When they are the main subject, images of drawings, paintings, printed material or photographs other than your own work are ineligible. Fractals and/or clip art are ineligible. Nothing identifying the entrant should appear in or on the image.

PHYSICAL REQUIREMENTS:

The digital images must be formatted such that the maximum pixel dimensions are 1400 by 1050 with a resolution of 150 pixels/inch. The final JPEG file size should be between 500-750 KB.  The sRGB color space is preferred for projection. 

The maker must define and name which category (pictorial-I, pictorial-II, monochrome, altered reality, or special subject) they wish the image to be entered in, as follows: 

Pictorial I:  P-I - maker’s name - title

            Pictorial II:  P-II - maker’s name – title

            Monochrome:  M - Maker’s name - title

            Altered Reality:  AR - maker’s name - title

            Selected Subject:  S - maker’s name - title

Failing to indicate the category will result in the Digital Coordinator assigning a category.  If there is any question whether the image is Pictorial I or Pictorial II, Monochrome, Altered Reality or Special Subject, the decision of the Digital Coordinator will be final.

IMAGE ELIGIBILITY

Only members in good standing may submit images.

An image may never be entered in more than one category.

Images receiving less than eight (8) may be resubmitted at any time in the same category in periodic critiques.

Images receiving eight (8) or more may NEVER be resubmitted in any digital category.

  End-of Year Competition:  Only images submitted during the year will be accepted for the end-of-the-year competition.  Up to four images may be submitted in the Pictorial categories and up to three images in Monochrome.  There will not be an end-of-the year category for Altered Reality or Special Subject.

  AWARDS:

PERIODIC CRITIQUES – 1st, 2nd, 3rd Place & Best of Show ribbons. One Best of Show award shall be selected from 1st place winners in all categories. Award Ribbons - scores of nine (9); Honorable Mention ribbons - scores of eight (8) or eight and one - half (8 l/2)

END-OF-THE-YEAR COMPETITION - 1st, 2nd, and 3rd Place .  Best-of-Show - one Best of Show award shall be selected from 1st place winners in the three categories.

HI-POINT AWARDS – (1st, 2nd, and 3rd) will be presented based on the total scores for the year in each category. In order to be eligible for a Hi-Point Certificate Awards, the maker must have entered seven (7) images in the Pictorial categories and three (3) images in Monochrome, two (2) images in Altered Reality.  There is not a special subject category.  

FAQs

HOW IS MY AVERAGE SCORE DETERMINED?

Scores are totaled and then divided by the number of entries.  

HOW DO I FIND OUT WHAT DIVISION I AM IN?

Past entrants will receive an email giving their average score from the previous year and their division.

MAY I ENTER MY DIGITAL IMAGE IN A PRINT CRITIQUE?

Yes, you may enter any Digital Image in any Print Critique.

THE JUDGE MISUNDERSTOOD MY PRINT.  CAN I EXPLAIN IT TO HIM/HER?

No one is permitted to make comments regarding images or judging that may be overheard

by the judge (s).

Home